New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew

19 October 2024 · MLS · 2024

Full time 2 – 3

Half-time: 0–2

  • Emil Forsberg 78’, 87’ (pen)
  • Aziel Jackson 2’
  • Yevhen Cheberko 14’
  • Malte Amundsen 90+7’

Match summary

Columbus Crew took a 3-2 win at New York Red Bulls, with the winner arriving in stoppage time. Columbus Crew led 2-0 at half-time.

In the first half, Aziel Jackson put Columbus Crew ahead with a header in the 2nd minute and Yevhen Cheberko made it 0-2 in the 14th minute. In the second half, Emil Forsberg pulled one back to make it 1-2 in the 78th minute, Forsberg equalised from the penalty spot in the 87th minute, and Malte Amundsen won it in stoppage time.

New York Red Bulls can feel hard done by, creating 2.29 expected goals (xG) from 13 shots to Columbus Crew's 1.69 from 19.

Key events

New York Red Bulls Columbus Crew
S. SchwarzManagerArgument
0’
Kick-off
2’
Aziel JacksonHeader0-1 (Columbus Crew)
4’
Aziel JacksonShot on target
14’
Yevhen CheberkoLeft foot shot0-2 (Columbus Crew)
Felipe CarballoShot on target
16’
Lewis MorganShot on target
30’
35’
Derrick JonesFoul
38’
Cucho HernándezShot on target
Felipe CarballoShot on target
44’
45+2’
Max ArfstenFoul
Half-time0-2
46’
Jacen Russell RoweDerrick Jones
Cameron HarperPeter Stroud
46’
47’
Malte AmundsenFoul
Second half underway
Lewis MorganShot on target
51’
Cameron HarperVAR: No penalty
55’
58’
Cucho HernándezShot on target
62’
Christian RamirezAziel Jackson
63’
Diego RossiCucho Hernández
Serge NgomaFelipe Carballo
67’
Elias ManoelDante Vanzeir
67’
73’
Sean ZawadzkiAlexandru Mățan
Emil ForsbergLeft foot shot1-2 (New York Red Bulls)
78’
80’
DeJuan JonesMax Arfsten
Wikelman CarmonaDaniel Edelman
80’
Emil ForsbergPenalty2-2 (New York Red Bulls)
87’
Aidan O'ConnorAndres Reyes
88’
Serge NgomaFoul
89’
Lewis MorganShot on target
90+3’
90+7’
Malte AmundsenLeft foot shot2-3 (Columbus Crew)
Full-time2-3

How the chances added up

Running total of expected goals (xG) for each side through the match. xG rates each chance by how often similar shots are scored. A goal is marked where it was scored.

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0’ 15’ 30’ 45’ 60’ 75’ 90’ HT 2.29 1.69 2’ Aziel Jackson (Columbus Crew), 0-1 2’ 14’ Yevhen Cheberko (Columbus Crew), 0-2 14’ 78’ Emil Forsberg (New York Red Bulls), 1-2 78’ 87’ Emil Forsberg (New York Red Bulls), 2-2 87’ 90+7’ Malte Amundsen (Columbus Crew), 2-3 90+7’ 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0’ 15’ 30’ 45’ 60’ 75’ 90’ HT 2.29 1.69 2’ Aziel Jackson (Columbus Crew), 0-1 Jackson 2’ 14’ Yevhen Cheberko (Columbus Crew), 0-2 Cheberko 14’ 78’ Emil Forsberg (New York Red Bulls), 1-2 Forsberg 78’ 87’ Emil Forsberg (New York Red Bulls), 2-2 Forsberg 87’ 90+7’ Malte Amundsen (Columbus Crew), 2-3 Amundsen 90+7’
New York Red Bulls 2.29 xGColumbus Crew 1.69 xG Goal

Tap a goal for the scorer and score.

Shot map

Every shot and where it was taken from.

 Columbus Crew attacking New York Red Bulls attacking 
87’ Emil Forsberg (New York Red Bulls), penalty, 0.79 xG, goal 40’ Andres Herrera (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.53 xG, off target 51’ Lewis Morgan (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.52 xG, saved 30’ Lewis Morgan (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.24 xG, saved 44’ Felipe Carballo (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.15 xG, saved 2’ Aziel Jackson (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.14 xG, goal 4’ Aziel Jackson (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.14 xG, saved 78’ Emil Forsberg (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.15 xG, goal 41’ Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.12 xG, blocked 61’ Emil Forsberg (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.10 xG, hit the woodwork 14’ Yevhen Cheberko (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.09 xG, goal 47’ Aziel Jackson (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.09 xG, blocked 77’ Elias Manoel (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.08 xG, off target 59’ Max Arfsten (Columbus Crew), from a corner, 0.08 xG, blocked 72’ Jacen Russell Rowe (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.07 xG, off target 23’ Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.07 xG, blocked 51’ Cameron Harper (New York Red Bulls), from a corner, 0.07 xG, hit the woodwork 90’ Dylan Chambost (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.06 xG, off target 8’ Felipe Carballo (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.06 xG, off target 16’ Felipe Carballo (New York Red Bulls), set piece, 0.06 xG, saved 58’ Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.05 xG, saved 16’ Sean Nealis (New York Red Bulls), set piece, 0.04 xG, off target 38’ Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.04 xG, saved 17’ Yevhen Cheberko (Columbus Crew), from a corner, 0.03 xG, off target 10’ Max Arfsten (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.03 xG, off target 16’ Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.03 xG, blocked 90+3’ Lewis Morgan (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.03 xG, saved 59’ Aziel Jackson (Columbus Crew), from a corner, 0.03 xG, blocked 60’ Max Arfsten (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.03 xG, off target 90+5’ Diego Rossi (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.03 xG, off target 90+7’ Malte Amundsen (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.03 xG, goal 62’ Lewis Morgan (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.01 xG, blocked 87’ Emil Forsberg (New York Red Bulls), penalty, 0.79 xG, goal 40’ Andres Herrera (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.53 xG, off target 51’ Lewis Morgan (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.52 xG, saved 30’ Lewis Morgan (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.24 xG, saved 44’ Felipe Carballo (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.15 xG, saved 78’ Emil Forsberg (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.15 xG, goal 2’ Aziel Jackson (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.14 xG, goal 4’ Aziel Jackson (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.14 xG, saved 41’ Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.12 xG, blocked 61’ Emil Forsberg (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.10 xG, hit the woodwork 14’ Yevhen Cheberko (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.09 xG, goal 47’ Aziel Jackson (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.09 xG, blocked 59’ Max Arfsten (Columbus Crew), from a corner, 0.08 xG, blocked 77’ Elias Manoel (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.08 xG, off target 72’ Jacen Russell Rowe (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.07 xG, off target 23’ Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.07 xG, blocked 51’ Cameron Harper (New York Red Bulls), from a corner, 0.07 xG, hit the woodwork 90’ Dylan Chambost (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.06 xG, off target 16’ Felipe Carballo (New York Red Bulls), set piece, 0.06 xG, saved 8’ Felipe Carballo (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.06 xG, off target 58’ Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.05 xG, saved 16’ Sean Nealis (New York Red Bulls), set piece, 0.04 xG, off target 38’ Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.04 xG, saved 10’ Max Arfsten (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.03 xG, off target 17’ Yevhen Cheberko (Columbus Crew), from a corner, 0.03 xG, off target 16’ Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.03 xG, blocked 90+3’ Lewis Morgan (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.03 xG, saved 60’ Max Arfsten (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.03 xG, off target 90+7’ Malte Amundsen (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.03 xG, goal 59’ Aziel Jackson (Columbus Crew), from a corner, 0.03 xG, blocked 90+5’ Diego Rossi (Columbus Crew), open play, 0.03 xG, off target 62’ Lewis Morgan (New York Red Bulls), open play, 0.01 xG, blocked
Size shows xG Goal On target Off target or blocked

Hover or tap a shot for the player, minute and xG.

Lineups

New York Red Bulls 4-3-1-2 Starting XI
Coronel
Tolkin
Reyes 88’
Nealis
Donkor
Stroud 46’
Edelman 80’
Carballo 67’
Forsberg 2
Vanzeir 67’
Morgan
Columbus Crew 3-4-2-1 Starting XI
Hagen
Amundsen
Cheberko
Camacho
Chambost
Jones 46’
Arfsten 80’
Herrera
Jackson 62’
Mățan 73’
Hernández 63’

Player stats

Goalkeeper1 player
Carlos Coronel
90′ 3 3 20 – – – – –
Defenders4 players
Andres Reyes Taken off
88′ 2 2 2 5 3 27 1 – – –
Sean Nealis
90′ 1 2 2 3 2 46 – – – –
John Tolkin
90′ – – – – – 32 1 – – –
Aidan O'Connor Came on as a substitute
12′ – 1 – – – 2 – – – –
Midfielders8 players
Ronald Donkor
90′ – – 26 – 0.06 2 2 4 1 1 –
Peter Stroud Taken off
45′ – – 18 – 0.00 1 – 3 1 2 –
Daniel Edelman Taken off
80′ – – 37 1 0.01 – 1 3 1 2 –
Felipe Carballo Taken off
67′ – – 20 – 0.01 1 2 3 1 1 –
Emil Forsberg
90′ 2 – 15 1 0.03 3 – 6 – 1 –
Cameron Harper Came on as a substitute
45′ – – 12 – 0.02 1 1 3 – 1 –
Serge Ngoma Came on as a substitute
23′ – – 6 – 0.00 – – – 1 –
Wikelman Carmona Came on as a substitute
10′ – – 5 – 0.00 – 1 – – – –
Forwards3 players
Dante Vanzeir Taken off
67′ – – – – – 0.49 3 2 – 14 –
Lewis Morgan
90′ – 1 4 3 0.80 0.24 4 5 – 27 –
Elias Manoel Came on as a substitute
23′ – – 1 – 0.08 0.00 1 1 1 3 –
Came on Taken off Sent off Red is the most in that position for the team

Every player who took the pitch, starters first and then substitutes. A dash means none. xG and xA are expected goals and assists.

Form going into the game

New York Red Bulls LDLWL
Columbus Crew WDLWW

Last five league games before this one, oldest first. Select one to open it.

Previous and next meeting

 Previous meeting: Columbus Crew 3-0 New York Red Bulls, 16 Mar 24 Next meeting: New York Red Bulls 0-0 Columbus Crew, 30 Aug 25  All New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew meetings

Shots, expected goals, timeline, lineups, team and player statistics from Bzzoiro Sports Data (sports.bzzoiro.com). Results and odds from football-data.co.uk.