Match summary
Barnsley and Horsham could not be separated, 3-3 after 90 minutes. It was 2-2 at half-time. Horsham won the first-round.
In the first half, Max Watters put Barnsley ahead in the 14th minute, Shamir Fenelon equalised in the 22nd minute, James Hammond put Horsham in front from the penalty spot in the 38th minute, and Fabio Jaló equalised in first-half stoppage time. In the second half, Maël de Gevigney put Barnsley back in front in the 64th minute and Tom Richards equalised in the 81st minute.